reflection of Dr Gibson's labours than on the state of current research into Hanoverian religion. We are only just beginning to uncover the lost world of the eighteenth century, especially at the local level, and it is likely that in a decade or two the picture will look very different from that sketched in this book. Dr Gibson's eighteenth century can seem slightly old-fashioned; there is more here about bishops, squires and parsons than about commerce, civility and empire. A volume of this nature can, of course, never be comprehensive, nor suit all readers. There are, however, some peculiar omissions, both of subject matter-such as the Trinitarian, Deist and Subscription controversies, the Latitudinarians, and the impact of science, the Enlightenment and the Industrial Revolution-and of historical debates-surely E. P. Thompson's and Jonathan Clark's work merits brief discussion? And yet, paradoxically, at times this collection simply seems to be attempting too much, with the concomitant danger of skating too quickly over important differences or assuming too much on the part of the student reader. A glossary, chronology, and guide to further reading might have made this a more user-friendly work for the student. And what would be even more helpful is a work of synthesis and interpretation to accompany this source-book. It is becoming increasingly obvious to researchers that the eighteenth century is part of 'the long English Reformation', that issues were being worked out within the established church, Dissent, and English and Welsh society which went back to the sixteenth century. It may be asking too much for a collection of this sort to tackle issues like clericalism, pluralism, voluntarism, or antipopery, but even as it stands Dr Gibson's valuable volume will be a helpful tool for those grappling with these bigger questions. The committed student will learn much from this collection. JOHN SPURR Swansea Politics IN Eighteenth-Century WALES. By Peter D. G. Thomas. University ofWales Press, Cardiff, 1998. Pp. xvi, 288. £ 25.00. It was an excellent idea to make use of Peter Thomas's unrivalled knowledge of Welsh parliamentary history, exploiting and augmenting his, work over the years for the History of Parliament. The flavour is distinctly Namierite, partly because some of the original research was done in the 1950s, partly because Wales, before it was transformed by coal and Methodism, was a relatively undeveloped land, dominated by the gentry. Its political life had
This text was generated automatically from the scanned page and has not been checked. Typical character accuracy is in excess of 99%, but this leaves one error per 100 characters.
The National Library of Wales has created and published this digital version of the journal under a licence granted by the publisher. The material it contains may be used for all purposes while respecting the moral rights of the creators.